Salary AI Book a Demo

Insurance Claims Investigator Salary in New York

How much does an Insurance Claims Investigator make in New York? As of September 01, 2026, the average salary for an Insurance Claims Investigator in New York is $67,329 per year, which breaks down to an hourly rate of $32.

However, an Insurance Claims Investigator's salary can vary significantly. Here's a look at the typical salary range:

  • Top Earners (90th percentile): $81,688
  • Majority Range (25th-75th percentile): $60,238 to $74,845
  • Entry-Level (10th percentile): $53,783
Salary Factors Salary by Experience Related Job Salaries Top Paying Cities Explore Related Jobs

Check out Insurance Claims Investigator Job Openings in New York

Key Factors That Influence Insurance Claims Investigator Salaries

An Insurance Claims Investigator's salary isn't a fixed number. It's shaped by several important factors. Below, we'll explore how your years of experience, geographic location and company size can directly affect your earning potential.

How Experience Level Affects Insurance Claims Investigator Salaries?

Experience is a primary driver of an Insurance Claims Investigator's salary. As you build your skills and take on more complex tasks, your compensation generally increases. Here's how the average salary grows at different career stages:

  • Entry-Level (less than 1 year): $65,763
  • Early Career (1-2 years): $77,484
  • Mid-Level (2-4 years): $100,734
  • Senior-Level (5-8 years): $127,461
  • Expert (over 8 years): $142,678
Job RoleYears of ExperienceAverage Salary
Insurance Claims Investigator less than 1 year $65,763
Underwriter II - Life 1-2 years $77,484
Underwriter III - Life 2-4 years $100,734
Underwriting Supervisor - Life 5-8 years $127,461
Underwriting Manager - Life over 8 years $142,678

How Do Insurance Claims Investigator Salaries Vary from State to State?

Your salary can change significantly depending on where you work. States with a higher cost of living and strong industrial sectors often pay more to attract Insurance Claims Investigators. For example, consider the average annual salaries in these key locations:

  • District of Columbia: $70,122.
  • California: $69,856.
  • Massachusetts: $68,925.

Top Paying Cities for Insurance Claims Investigator

Salaries can also vary between different cities. Major metropolitan areas or cities with a high demand for technicians often offer more competitive pay. Here are a few examples of average annual salaries in different U.S. cities:

  • Holtsville: $69,489
  • Brentwood: $69,372
  • Brightwaters: $68,754

Insurance Claims Investigator Salary by Industry: Top Paying Sectors

For Insurance Claims Investigator roles, the industry you choose can affect earning potential by as much as 50% (the gap between the highest and lowest paying industries). Data shows that the Financial Services and Healthcare sectors offer the strongest compensation, at 30% above the average. In contrast, Insurance Claims Investigator positions in Insurance or Edu., Gov't. & Nonprofit typically offer lower base pay, as these industries often view Insurance Claims Investigator as a support function rather than a direct revenue driver.

The top paying industries for an Insurance Claims Investigator

Industry Sector Average Annual Salary Average Hourly Rate Pay vs.Avg
Financial Services $87,527 $42.0 30%
Healthcare $80,794 $39.0 20%

Insurance Claims Investigator Salary: Hourly Rate, Weekly Pay, and Monthly Pay

Understanding how an Insurance Claims Investigator's annual salary breaks down can help with budgeting. Below, you can see the average hourly rate, weekly pay, and monthly pay for this role. Use the buttons to switch between different pay periods.

  • Yearly
  • Monthly
  • Weekly
  • Hourly
  • Table View
Last Updated on September 01, 2026
$60,238
Average $67,329/year
$74,845
$5,020
Average $5,611/month
$6,237
$1,158
Average $1,295/week
$1,439
$29
Average $32/hour
$36
Annual Salary Monthly Pay Weekly Pay Hourly Wage
75th Percentile $74,845 $6,237 $1,439 $36
Average $67,329 $5,611 $1,295 $32
25th Percentile $60,238 $5,020 $1,158 $29

Find Your Next Insurance Claims Investigator Job

Ready to take the next step in your career? Browse thousands of current Insurance Claims Investigator job openings on our job board. Use the search bar below to find your perfect match.

  • UnitedHealth Group | Syracuse, NY

    Insurance Investigator

    UnitedHealth Group | Syracuse, NY

    Optum is a global organization that delivers care, aided by technology, to help millions of people live healthier lives. The work you do with our team will... more

    8 Days Ago

  • Lemieux & Associates LLC | Buffalo, NY

    SIU Claims Investigator

    Lemieux & Associates LLC | Buffalo, NY

    Job Description. Job Description. Come grow with us. Lemieux & Associates, a national leader in the investigative industry, is seeking experienced SIU/Clai... more

    6 Days Ago

  • Lemieux & Associates LLC | Rochester, NY

    SIU Claims Investigator

    Lemieux & Associates LLC | Rochester, NY

    Job Description. Job Description. Come grow with us. Lemieux & Associates, a national leader in the investigative industry, is seeking experienced SIU/Clai... more

    6 Days Ago

  • Lemieux & Associates LLC | Albany, NY

    SIU Claims Investigator

    Lemieux & Associates LLC | Albany, NY

    Job Description. Job Description. Come grow with us. Lemieux & Associates, a national leader in the investigative industry, is seeking experienced SIU/Clai... more

    9 Days Ago

  • Marubeni America | New York City, NY

    Insurance Claims Specialist

    Marubeni America | New York City, NY

    Insurance Claims SpecialistWe are seeking an experienced and independent Insurance Claims Specialist with 7years of multi-line claims experience to manage ... more

    6 Days Ago

  • DePaul | Rochester, NY

    Job Insurance and Claims Coordinator

    DePaul | Rochester, NY

    Insurance And Claims CoordinatorDePaul is looking for an experienced Insurance and Claims Coordinator to manage the organization's insurance procurement an... more

    6 Days Ago

For Employees

Analyze the market and your qualifications to negotiate your salary with confidence.

Get a Salary Increase

Search thousands of open positions to find your next opportunity.

Search Job Openings

For Employers

Individualize employee pay based on unique job requirements and personal qualifications.

Adjust Employee Salary

Get the latest market price for benchmark jobs and jobs in your industry.

Price My Industry Jobs

Where Does Our Salary Data Come From?

Salary.com salary estimates, histograms, trends, and comparisons are derived from both employer job postings and third-party data sources. We also provide multiple percentiles of salary information for your reference, click here to know Why the Salary Midpoint Formula Is Crucial to Getting Pay Equity Right. With more online, real-time compensation data than any other website, Salary.com helps you determine your exact pay target.

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?

Salary.com's CompAnalyst platform offers:

  • Detailed skills and competency reports for specific positions
  • Job and employee pricing reports
  • Compensation data tools, salary structures, surveys and benchmarks.
Learn about CompAnalyst